Skip to content

Sonic Team head talks about the pressure of obtaining high reviews and Metacritic

The Sonic the Hedgehog franchise remains as popular as ever, perhaps even more so, but the games have generally struggled critically with reviewers quick to jump on the flaws. In a recent interview Sonic Team boss Takashi Iizuka acknowledged there have been issues but attributed this to budgets and lack of staff. Now that they have bigger budgets, Mr. Iizuka is confident things will continue to improve on the quality front. However, one thing the team feels is pressure to achieve a high Metacritic score (90+), which they have yet to achieve. Sonic Team isn’t alone in this as development teams are usually offered nice bonuses for a high Metascore on the popular review aggregation site.

To dig a bit deeper into the topic of quality, Sonic games used to see fairly inconsistent reviews scores, whereas recent releases seem to have become more consistent. What do you think is the reason for that?

Iizuka: The biggest factor is the resources we can allocate to them. When the Sonic brand was struggling, we simply had less money to invest in each title, so we had to make do with what we had. Now, however, expectations for the Sonic series have risen, and we have more resources to put into it. Being able to make games with greater care as a result of that is a major factor.

Would you say those parts of past games that made you think “I wish this had been a little better” were directly related to a lack of resources?

Iizuka: I think the lack of resources was a very significant factor. Now that our development teams have grown considerably, if, for example, one title looks like it might not make its deadline, staff from elsewhere can come in to support the project, allowing us to maintain both quality and stay on schedule. We now have that kind of support structure within the team.

Compared to the past, do you feel there’s more breathing room in development now?

Iizuka: Thanks to that support system, we’re now in a position where we can properly deliver high-quality games to users. However, that also means the pressure has increased.

At this point, selling a million copies is almost a given for the Sonic series.

Iizuka: We can’t afford to let our Metacritic scores drop, either, so there’s also more pressure to make games that can achieve high scores, as well as the dilemma of what to prioritize (laughs). I think game development is tough because it involves both kinds of struggles.

22 thoughts on “Sonic Team head talks about the pressure of obtaining high reviews and Metacritic”

  1. The franchise remains popular thanks to people who mock at its questionable quality, people who hate buy and of course the minority who are fans and defend whatever bone Iizuka throws at them.

      1. The comment asked them to “stop with the shitty sonic news”. So that was the reason they commented, because they hate the sonic news on a Nintendo News site. Plus, Sonic is lame.

    1. It is clear this article is about Sonic. If there is an article headline about something you don’t care about, you have the option to not open it. This is more effective than telling the author to “stop”. Plus some people enjoy the Sonic news.

  2. Don’t blame the games quality on a lower budget, blame the low review scores for the rushed games, and their glitches. But since they have been given more time to work on more mainline entries, I hope we can get something good out of this hedgehog.

  3. You just can’t rush the games. As for the budget, just look at team cherry and silksong. Absolutely no where near the budget or staff, yet look at the results

    1. Yeah. tho theres the obvious Difference expectations. Like yeah is obviously a 2d indie metroidvania is gonna have a lower budget than the 3d platformer from a big company. But the big company has to develop their game on deadlines. And id imagine it’s not hitting those is a good way to get fired. If i remember correctly frontiers was actually given more dev time than usual so i think sonic team has more problems than just not rushing.

  4. Well ya, when your management cares more about the deadline than the video game, good chance you got a rushed turd wrapped up with a bow. But if Sonic Team also doesn’t have skilled game designers, more time and money wont fix things either and you need to outsource. Which they did with Sonic Boom, revealingly. But that was some wild direction to take

  5. Are companies still chasing Metacritic scores?
    I thought people would have realized by now that sites like Metacritic are simply places where different people’s opinions are collected and then combined into a general rating, and not places that give objective assessments to works.

    1. Video games are an inherently subjective art form.
      I imagine your idea of “objective assessment” is really just your own personal opinions that you present as facts to mask your insecurity.

      1. This is not an attempt to hide one’s insecurities.
        Websites like Metacritic were never created to provide objective ratings; they were always created as sites that simply collect different opinions and combine them into one overall rating.

        1. They were never created to provide “objective” ratings because video games are, again, an inherently subjective art form.
          But by all means, please link a website that provides fully objective critique of games without any personal bias. I’m waiting.

          1. I don’t know what you’re trying to prove.
            I didn’t try to prove that other sites have objective ratings (none of them have objective ratings), I just think that it’s stupid to chase ratings on Metacritic or other similar sites (like OpenCritic), since they are not sites that provide objective ratings.

            1. Anti-Narcissist League

              What exactly are YOU trying to prove, talking about “objective assessment” while also basically admitting that such a thing doesn’t actually exist for gaming?

              Obviously gaming companies care about review scores, it shows how their customers have reacted to their work and give them indications on what worked well and criticism on what needs to be improved.
              They also frequently influence the general public on whether to buy a game or not, as more people are likely to buy a highly rated game than a low rated one, so there’s a monetary influence too.
              Obviously not every review is helpful, but all-together they form useful information for these companies.

              This is all extremely obvious, and I really don’t understand why you struggle to comprehend it.

              Honestly your entire argument here is such a nothing-burger, there is no such thing as objectivity when it comes to gaming reviews. There will always be bias and differing takes from different corners of the gaming community.
              To think otherwise, or to think that your own personal opinion is “objective” in any way, is pure narcissism.

  6. Well-written article with valuable points about timing and concentration. These skills connect well with games that require quick reactions and careful movement. You can check out geometry dash online for an engaging platform experience. It combines creative stages, rhythm-inspired gameplay, and challenging obstacles. Each new section provides another opportunity to practice, improve timing, and become more confident.

Leave a Reply