Nintendo review Switch

Review: Pokémon Sword and Shield for Nintendo Switch

Pokémon Sword and Shield are a big deal for Pokémon and Nintendo fans as a whole. Not only do they mark the start of a brand-new generation — they’re also the very first original titles in the core Pokémon franchise that were built from the ground up for a home console. Thanks to the portability function of Nintendo Switch, this transition feels completely natural and was a necessary move in order to continue pushing the iconic series forward.

Set in the UK-inspired Galar region, the games put you in the shoes of a young Trainer who sets off on a journey to catch Pokémon, battle other people and meet new friends along the way, with an ultimate goal of becoming the best in the land. This formula will instantly feel familiar to anyone who’s played a core Pokémon title before. While the nostalgic factor is there, you can expect a ton of handholding, especially during the early parts where your gameplay is interrupted every few steps for a character to tell you exactly where to go, no matter how obvious it was in the first place. Nevertheless, this structure will be appreciated by newcomers and is suitable for those who may be new to RPGs in general.

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

Due to utilizing a more capable graphical system, Pokémon Sword and Shield are easily the most appealing Pokémon games when it comes to visuals. Galar is portrayed as a vibrant and bustling region that serves as home to humans and Pokémon alike. You can see Pokémon roaming around fields, swimming in lakes and even flying in the air — bringing the world one step closer to life. However, that sense of realism is diminished as the result of certain limitations; throughout your journey you’ll come across NPCs, including Pokémon, that seem to pop up out of thin air.

The lively aspect is enhanced by the animation of cutscenes, which are more dynamic than ever before and manage to drive the narrative in an engaging way. But voiceovers are nowhere to be found, forcing you to read text while trying to enjoy what’s happening on screen. For a franchise that has a full-blown animated series under its belt, voice actors should be utilized for the games as well in this day and age. Similarly, screeches of Pokémon sound dated and could use the help of actual cries with modernized sound effects. Outside of cutscenes, animations could also use a facelift, particularly during battles and when characters are interacting with each other. The majority of movements in these categories appear generic and repetitive, but they don’t necessarily take away from the overall aroma of the game world.

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

A number of notable quality-of-life improvements have been implemented. For example, trading and communication capabilities are integrated in the pause menu, allowing you to access them anytime. Additionally, the ability to fast travel is made possible early on and battle options are more streamlined with a set of clear choices at hand. Factors like these are responsible for offering a more seamless experience that’s only strengthened by how you don’t have to deal with HMs (Hopefully those things never make a comeback).

Akin to previous entries in the series, the difficulty factor is pretty much nonexistent for veterans. The games follow the same familiar formula in that you start off with nothing, meet your rival, choose your first starter out of the same three types, encounter the same patterns of Pokémon types and set off on a predictable path that ultimately leads you to victory. Battles are extremely easy and beginner moves like Razor Leaf, Ember, Bubble or Peck can take you far. Furthermore, each Pokémon in your party gains Exp. Points by default. Exp. Points can also be gained via various other methods such as the adorable Pokémon Camp and Poké Jobs, making leveling up easier than ever. Most of the journey is overtly linear, leaving little to no room for exploration outside the Wild Area.

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

There are several Wild Area locations for players to explore throughout Galar. Each area consists of a vast expanse of nature that houses a plethora of Pokémon within their respective habitats. If you wanted to, you can very well fill up your party with a variety of types from the first Wild Area. You can freely move the camera horizontally and vertically to an extent. But for something that was hyped heavily by the developers at Game Freak themselves, camera movement is restrictive and there relatively isn’t much to do compared to other open-world adventures.

At the start of your journey, you’re introduced to the Dynamax phenomenon, which enables Pokémon to grow to an enormous size with an arsenal set of powerful moves during battle. Your Pokémon can undergo this change and you can catch new creatures in the same state in specific locations, predominantly in the Wild Area. You can join up with three other players to take on Dynamax Pokémon in Max Raid Battles. If you don’t want to connect with them, you also have the option of siding with NPCs to decrease the wait time. It pretty much feels the same since the objective doesn’t change, so you won’t be missing out either way.

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

Gigantamax is a similar feature that takes it a couple steps further by altering a Pokémon’s form and equipping them with a unique move. In addition to contributing toward more vigorous battles, the Dynamax and Gigantamax phenomena do more than enough to fill the voids of Mega Evolutions and Z-Moves. The same can’t necessarily be said about the infamous missing Pokémon throughout Galar, especially if some of your favorites were cut off, but you’re bound to find at least six Pokémon that you’ll be satisfied to add to your party. Nevertheless, completionists will be left disappointed in the end.

Pokémon Sword and Shield feel exactly like a Pokémon game, which is far from being a bad thing, but a major change in the formula is necessary in order to significantly mix things up. It’s not broken by any means, but fans who’ve been involved with the series for over 20 years now expect more at this point. It goes without saying that newcomers will feel right at home, and catching Pokémon and filling your Pokédex is still as addictive as ever. Looking ahead, the Wild Area in particular is a sign of good things to come for the Pokémon franchise.

7.5/10

A review copy of Pokémon Sword on Nintendo Switch was provided by Nintendo UK.

8 comments

  1. Although i’m glad that we finally got a console Pokemon I’m also slightly dissapointed that its still the same game as 20 years ago. Altough the same can be said about most Nintendo Franchises . Breath of the Wild and Metroid Prime where refreshing other than that not much has changed.

    Like

  2. And then we get the sunny positive reviews, for a game that’s founded on lies, laziness, and priority towards profits (ya know, $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$)

    It’s in the modding community’s hands now. This is officially war.

    Like

  3. I only played through one Pokemon game (Diamond) and thoroughly loved it. In fact, I loved it so much that I thought I’d be a fan forever, and buy every Pokemon game. BUT….the very next game that came out after Diamond (was it Black and White?), I instantly found myself feeling bored. It was only my 2nd Pokemon game and I was already suffering from the rinse and repeat gameplay. After that, it really made me wonder how the heck the Pokemon franchise stayed so popular all of these years.

    Perhaps I needed to be younger when the franchise first started in order to fully appreciate it forever. Or perhaps I haven’t been fair, and should have forced myself to played through that 2nd game. All I know is that I lost interest after Diamond and Pearl. There’s something annoying about trainers all over the region jumping out and challenging you to a battle over and over. That got SO tiresome. I was afraid to even talk to anyone in the games because they might try battling. I attempted Pokemon XD Gale Of Darkness, but again lost interest. I bought several other Pokemon spin-offs, simply because of being a collector (such as a few Mystery Dungeons), but never played them.

    I’ve always felt annoyed when new Pokemon games came out. Because I feel like I should have remained a fan, but just couldn’t. Maybe if I ever had kids that loved Pokemon, it would reignite my love for the series. But I’ll never have kids to know that. Oh well. That’s my story.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. You may find this interesting.

      I’ve been playing Pokemon since Red and Blue. I thoroughly enjoyed it as a kid. Even collected all 151 Pokemon.
      Gold and Silver then came out. I enjoyed those even more. I collected them all again except Celebi… which was impossible to catch in-game. Eventually I got an action replay and was able to acquire it and have some other fun.
      Ruby and Sapphire was next. I… enjoyed those. Maybe not as much as the past games.
      Diamond and Pearl came out and I was done. I remember getting it, beating it’s story in two days, and returning the game to the store. The campaign didn’t appeal to me and it was just too convoluted to even attempt to “catch em’ all” at that point.

      So, the first game you played and enjoyed was the quitting point for me. I think that’s because… well… you play one Pokemon game, you’ve pretty much played all of them. The devs really add nothing to each new game except an expansion of Pokemon and more artificial gates to keep you from more content. I think Gold and Silver was the only sequel to actually genuinely improve and build on the formula of the last game. It added day/night, new types, new pokemon, new map… BUT it didn’t discard the stuff of the past game because, well, they encouraged you to “catch em all”. You could get invested in Red and Blue and bring those investments into Gold and Silver. Even if you were just attached to the area and characters in Red/Blue, they still remained in Gold/Silver. Gold/Silver had a whole new map/region but you could also go back to the game’s first region and do stuff. You could even find the player character from Red/Blue hiding in a cave and challenge him as the game’s ultimate boss.

      But then the subsequent games, while adding some stuff, didn’t add a whole lot. Or tried to innovate the gameplay. All they did was recycle the same formula and add more Pokemon and more convoluted ways to access gated/exclusive content.

      I hate to make this long post even longer… but I’ll try to be brief. I stepped back into the series when XY came out. I was under the assumption “Surely the series has evolved now and it’ll be cool to see it’s foray into 3d on the 3DS.”
      I played it and… Nah. It was the same game and the story was even further down the road Ruby/Sapphire had stepped onto. Of course, ORAS came out and I was done after playing the demo.

      But then I bought Sun/Moon because it seemed like they were trying somewhat to be different. In a way, they did. In a lot of ways, they didn’t. It was my first time using the GTS feature though which was amazing imo. If you did want to “catch em all” it was the easiest most convient way to legally do it. But, if I read correctly… they took GTS out of Sword/Shield….

      Anyways… you get the picture. I’m a more skeptical gamer and even I keep giving Pokemon chance after chance to evolve. Somehow the series has acquired an infinite amount of benefits of the doubt and low expectations from it’s audience. I think it’s because gamer’s recognize there is something special here and potential to grow but the devs just keep hitting the B button on each new entry.

      Like

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: