The latest edition of UK publication EDGE magazine is now with subscribers and it contains a number of high-profile reviews including God of War on Sony’s PlayStation 4 and Sea of Thieves on Microsoft’s Xbox One console. Detective Pikachu and Scribblenauts Showdown were also reviewed and received a 6 and a 3 respectively. Here’s the review scores from issue 319
- God of War – 8
- Sea of Thieves – 7
- Far Cry 5 – 6
- A Way Out – 6
- Extinction – 3
- Scribblenauts Showdown – 3
- Minit – 6
- Detective Pikachu – 6
Yikes. I don’t usually trust reviews that gives scores, but they’re probably right about Scribblenauts showdown.
Wow, tough crowd.
I thought the new Scribblenauts looked like shit anyway
GOW – 8 : NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
SMO-10 and BOTW-10 : How cute
Resetera forums closed that post. Sony fans meltdown everywhere.
It’s silly for some of these Sony fans to get upset. Reviews are opinion based, not fact based. While Edge’s reviewer(s) thinks those games are an 8, 10, & 10, others might give them a 10, 8, & 8. Or a 10, 8, & 10. Or an 8, 10, & 8. Etc, etc. Anyone taking the “console wars” seriously are what’s wrong with this industry.
Tell that to this guy https://nintendoeverything.com/edge-319-review-scores/
he accused me of Nintendofanboyism. When I said that everyone have different opinions but he doesn’t want to stop and act like a hardcore sonyfanboy. I really don’t like GOW even I prefer Horizon and Far Cry 5 over emo Kratos(i like to call him that). Truly sad acting he like that and probably he will answer me again.
>Reviews are opinion based, not fact based.
Do you have any Idea how long I needed to read that?
>Anyone taking the “console wars” seriously are what’s wrong with this industry.
I needed to read that too.
Today we lose a battle. But not the war.
Edge, just wait for see the new weapon of our commander in action
Cool score for GoW4, but I’ll be the judge of what score I give the game… whenever I get around to playing it on my PS4 Pro, that is. lol If I had to rate other games I’ve played in the last 2 years, I’d give NieR: Automata a 10, FFXV a 7, Zelda: BotW a 7, & Until Dawn a 10.
Wow, I couldn’t believe the rating of GOW would land to 8. As expected it should be 10. Accuracy seems lost its way.
Feels like the scores for most or all of these games are one point too low.